Home Professional Hub Clinical Research Publications Head and neck IMPT probabilistic dose accumulation: Feasibility of a 2mm setup uncertainty setting

31 / 05 / 21

Head and neck IMPT probabilistic dose accumulation: Feasibility of a 2mm setup uncertainty setting


Abstract

Objective: To establish optimal robust optimization uncertainty settings for clinical head and neck cancer (HNC) patients undergoing 3D image-guided pencil beam scanning (PBS) proton therapy.

Methods: We analyzed ten consecutive HNC patients treated with 70 and 54.25 GyRBE to the primary and prophylactic clinical target volumes (CTV) respectively using intensity-modulated proton therapy (IMPT). Clinical plans were generated using robust optimization with 5 mm/3% setup/range uncertainties (RayStation v6.1). Additional plans were created for 4, 3, 2 and 1 mm setup and 3% range uncertainty and for 3 mm setup and 3%, 2% and 1% range uncertainty. Systematic and random error distributions were determined for setup and range uncertainties based on our quality assurance program. From these, 25 treatment scenarios were sampled for each plan, each consisting of a systematic setup and range error and daily random setup errors. Fraction doses were calculated on the weekly verification CT closest to the date of treatment as this was considered representative of the daily patient anatomy.

Results: Plans with a 2 mm/3% setup/range uncertainty setting adequately covered the primary and prophylactic CTV (V95 ≥ 99% in 98.8% and 90.8% of the treatment scenarios respectively). The average organ-at-risk dose decreased with 1.1 GyRBE/mm setup uncertainty reduction and 0.5 GyRBE/1% range uncertainty reduction. Normal tissue complication probabilities decreased by 2.0%/mm setup uncertainty reduction and by 0.9%/1% range uncertainty reduction.

Conclusion: The results of this study indicate that margin reduction below 3 mm/3% is possible but requires a larger cohort to substantiate clinical introduction.

Wagenaar D, Kierkels RGJ, van der Schaaf A, Meijers A, Scandurra D, Sijtsema NM, Korevaar EW, Steenbakkers RJHM, Knopf AC, Langendijk JA, Both S. Head and neck IMPT probabilistic dose accumulation: Feasibility of a 2 mm setup uncertainty setting. Radiother Oncol. 2021 Jan;154:45-52. doi: 10.1016/j.radonc.2020.09.001. Epub 2020 Sep 6. PMID: 32898561.

*Please refer to the Terms and Conditions of this website when leaving the site and viewing third party content. 

Consultants we currently work with (head & neck)

Dr Muthiah Sivaramalingam

Dr Muthiah Sivaramalingam has been a consultant in Clinical Oncology since 2007 and has been Principal Investigator for many clinical...

Read more
Dr Muthiah Sivaramalingam

Dr Shanmugasundaram Ramkumar

Dr Ramkumar is a Consultant Clinical Oncologist specialising in non-surgical treatment of Head and Neck cancer, Skull Base Tumours and...

Read more
Dr Shanmugasundaram Ramkumar

Dr Cheng Boon

Dr Cheng Boon is Consultant Clinical Oncologist at the Worcester Oncology Centre at Worcester Royal Hospital. He completed medical training...

Read more
Dr Cheng Boon

Dr Josef Kovarik

Dr Josef Kovarik is an acting consultant clinical oncologist and a Lead of ENT Oncology at the Northern Centre for Cancer...

Read more
Dr Josef Kovarik

Dr Eleanor Aynsley

Dr Aynsley graduated from Leeds Medical School in 1999. She did medical training in Durham, gaining MRCP in 2004. She...

Read more
Dr Eleanor Aynsley

Dr Russell Banner

Dr Russell Banner is a Consultant Clinical Oncologist based in South Wales. His undergraduate training was at Christ’s College, Cambridge...

Read more
Dr Russell Banner

Cancer treatments we offer

The Rutherford Cancer Centres provide high-quality cancer care by offering access to innovative and advanced treatment techniques using leading technology.

Consultants we work with

We provide exceptional patient support from diagnosis through to treatment and recovery, with leading consultants available at our centres across the country.

Centres across the UK

The Rutherford Cancer Centres provide cancer treatments and other healthcare services across the UK with our centres designed to put the patient experience first.

Contact Us

Get in Touch

If you'd like to speak to us about any of the treatments we offer please don’t hesitate to get in touch. Call us on 0800 210 0402 or

Our Trusted Healthcare Partners